Healer vs Scholar Ingots: Which Earns More in 2026?

Profession Income Overview: Healer vs Scholar Economics

Both professions unlock at level 13. Healer follows a direct income model with quantified rewards per activity, while Scholar operates through a crafting-based economy with variable market-dependent returns.

Healer Unlock:

• Location: Evercare Clinic, Qinghe
• Cost: 10,000 Coins to Yao Yaoyao
• Progression: Five Silver Needle Sect ranks (Keeper, Physician, Chief Physician, Medical Scholar, Divine Healer)

Scholar Unlock:

• Location: Deerforage Grove, Moonveil Mountain
• Cost: Free (skill-based)
• Process: Climb mountain → meet Yan Huaijin → talk with Wei Rujun (2nd floor) → win debate using Heart Stab card

For immediate resource access, Where Winds Meet top up through buffget provides competitive pricing and fast delivery.

Primary Income Streams

Healer per-patient rewards:

• 5,000 Treasure Coins
• 4 Career Notebooks
• 1,000 EXP
• 1,000 Zhou Coins

With 5-10 daily patients, Healers consistently generate 25,000 Treasure Coins. Qinghe has 12 patients, Kaifeng offers 17.

Scholar income:

• Career Notebooks from debate victories
• Talisman sales (variable market prices)
• Basic and Advanced Attribute buffs

Gift of Gab mini-game uses turn-based debate cards requiring strategic selection.

Season Shop Weekly Resources

Both professions rely on weekly resets:

• Career Notebooks: 4 Jade Fish each (500 weekly limit)
• Healer Giftboxes: 50 Jade Fish each (15 weekly limit)
• Scholar Giftboxes: 50 Jade Fish each (15 weekly limit)

This creates a resource ceiling affecting long-term progression.

Healer Ingot Earning Potential

Core gameplay: Use Wind Sense (V key/R3) to detect patients → activate Wind Vision to assess illness levels → click Diagnose when your mastery exceeds illness severity.

Patient Mastery Requirements

• Mao Da: 3,200 mastery
• Ye Mingyuan (Broken Bone): 3,900 mastery
• He Quniang (Water Gu): 3,900 mastery
• Luo Shaoqiang (Slight Fever): 5,300 mastery
• Zhu Xiaohai: 6,600 mastery

Physiotherapy treats bone injuries and diseases. Wind Vision reveals illness levels before treatment.

Daily Optimization Strategy

1. Start in Qinghe with lower-mastery patients (3,200-3,900)
2. Progress to higher-mastery patients as skill increases
3. Complete 5-10 treatments before daily reset
4. Collect 20-40 Career Notebooks daily
5. Accumulate 5,000-10,000 EXP

Rankings reset every Sunday. Consistent participation builds Silver Needle Sect rank.

Time Investment

Per patient treatment:

• Wind Sense detection: 30-60 seconds
• Diagnosis confirmation: 15-30 seconds
• Treatment completion: 45-90 seconds
• Total: 90-180 seconds

10 daily patients = 15-30 minutes of focused gameplay.

Scholar Ingot Earning Potential

Scholar income lacks direct coin rewards but offers Career Notebooks through debates. Gift of Gab card cycle:

• Heart Stab beats Infuriating Nitpicker
• Infuriating Nitpicker beats Yapping
• Yapping beats Wild Boasts
• Wild Boasts beats Heart Stab

Talisman Crafting Income

Scholars craft talismans granting Basic and Advanced Attribute buffs. Value fluctuates based on:

• Talisman quality and attribute bonuses
• Current market demand
• Competition from other Scholars
• Material acquisition costs

Buy Where Winds Meet Ingots through buffget's secure platform for crafting material acceleration.

Career Notebook Acquisition

Healers earn 4 Career Notebooks per patient. Scholars must win debates:

1. Locate debate opponents
2. Select counter-cards based on opponent choices
3. Win best-of-three or best-of-five matches
4. Collect Career Notebooks as rewards

Variable debate encounters create inconsistent earning rates.

Season Shop Strategy

Scholars face identical limitations:

• 500 Career Notebook weekly limit
• 15 Scholar Giftbox weekly limit
• Weekly ceiling: 2,750 Jade Fish (2,000 for notebooks + 750 for Giftboxes)

Head-to-Head Comparison

Healer daily earnings:

• Minimum: 25,000 Treasure Coins (5 patients × 5,000)
• Maximum: 50,000 Treasure Coins (10 patients × 5,000)
• Career Notebooks: 20-40 daily
• Bonus EXP: 5,000-10,000
• Zhou Coins: 5,000-10,000

Scholar daily earnings:

• No quantified coin rewards
• Career Notebooks from debates (variable)
• Talisman sales (market-dependent)
• Advanced Attribute buff demand (meta-dependent)

Time Requirements

Healer: 15-30 minutes for 10 treatments = guaranteed 50,000 Treasure Coins

Scholar: Variable time for:

• Locating debate opponents
• Completing debates (3-5 minutes each)
• Crafting talismans (material-dependent)
• Marketing items (auction house time)

Healer offers superior time efficiency for guaranteed returns.

Passive Income

Healer: None—all earnings require active treatment

Scholar passive potential:

• Auction house talisman listings (sell while offline)
• Bulk crafting sessions
• Market speculation

Benefits players with irregular schedules but requires market knowledge and capital.

Initial Investment and ROI

Healer:

• Upfront: 10,000 Coins
• ROI: After 2 patients (2 × 5,000 = 10,000)

Career Notebook progression:

• Keeper to Physician: 1-2 days
• Physician to Chief Physician: 3-5 days
• Chief Physician to Medical Scholar: 1-2 weeks
• Medical Scholar to Divine Healer: 2-4 weeks

With 20-40 daily Career Notebooks, steady progression without additional investment.

Scholar:

• Unlock cost: Free (skill-based)
• Ongoing expenses: crafting materials, auction fees
• ROI: Variable based on talisman sales

30-Day Projections

Healer:

• Daily: 25,000-50,000 Treasure Coins
• Monthly: 750,000-1,500,000 Treasure Coins
• Career Notebooks: 600-1,200
• Bonus EXP: 150,000-300,000

Scholar:

• Highly variable based on talisman sales
• No guaranteed coin floor

Resource Management Strategy

Season Shop weekly reset creates strategic requirements. Both professions compete for 500 Career Notebooks (4 Jade Fish each = 2,000 Jade Fish).

Jade Fish Acquisition

To purchase maximum weekly notebooks:

• Complete daily quests
• Participate in weekly events
• Convert currencies through exchange
• Purchase Giftboxes (15 weekly limit)

Healers fund purchases using guaranteed 25,000-50,000 daily income. Scholars rely on talisman sales.

Giftbox Value

50 Jade Fish each, 15 weekly limit:

• Total cost: 750 Jade Fish
• Remaining budget: 1,250 Jade Fish = 312 Career Notebooks

Advanced Income Strategies

Healer optimization:

1. Route optimization: Map all 12 Qinghe + 17 Kaifeng patients
2. Mastery matching: Prioritize patients matching current healing mastery
3. Daily reset timing: Complete treatments before reset
4. Physiotherapy specialization: Focus on bone injuries and diseases

Scholar market timing:

1. Meta analysis: Craft talismans for popular build attributes
2. Bulk crafting: Create inventory during low-demand, sell at peak
3. Debate efficiency: Master card cycle for quick wins
4. Material stockpiling: Purchase during market lows

Profession synergy:

• Healer + Gathering: Farm materials while traveling
• Scholar + Research: Unlock rare talisman blueprints
• Either + Auction House Mastery: Maximize sales efficiency

Common Mistakes

Healer errors:

• Attempting high-mastery patients prematurely
• Ignoring Wind Vision before diagnosis
• Poor route planning
• Neglecting Season Shop purchases before reset

Scholar pitfalls:

• Crafting unpopular talismans
• Debate card mismanagement
• Overpricing crafted items
• Insufficient material reserves

Universal errors:

• Missing weekly Season Shop resets (500 Career Notebooks lost)
• Inefficient Jade Fish spending
• Ignoring Giftbox value
• Poor progression planning

Final Verdict

Healer delivers superior quantified income for guaranteed returns. 25,000-50,000 daily Treasure Coins + 20-40 Career Notebooks = predictable progression with 15-30 minute daily investment.

Best for Active Players (4+ hours daily)

Healer maximization:

• Complete all 10 daily treatments
• Farm additional healing materials
• Participate in healing rankings
• Purchase maximum Season Shop resources

Scholar commitment:

• Extensive debate participation
• Continuous talisman crafting and market monitoring
• Material farming
• Auction house management

Best for Casual Players (1-2 hours daily)

Healer benefits:

• 15-30 minute commitment = 25,000-50,000 Treasure Coins
• No market dependency
• Predictable Silver Needle Sect progression
• Minimal auction house interaction

Scholar demands more time for uncertain returns.

When to Switch

Consider switching when:

• Healer to Scholar: Maximized healing mastery, seeking crafting variety
• Scholar to Healer: Talisman market saturation reduces profitability
• Either: Major updates shift profession balance

10,000 Coin Healer unlock creates minimal switching barriers.

FAQ

How many ingots can a Healer earn per day? Healers earn 25,000-50,000 Treasure Coins daily through patient treatments. Each heal generates 5,000 Treasure Coins. Treating 5-10 patients provides consistent income plus 20-40 Career Notebooks.

What's the fastest way for Scholars to make ingots? Craft meta-relevant attribute buff talismans, win debates for Career Notebooks, and monitor market demand. Bulk craft during material price lows to maximize profit margins.

Do Healers earn more from treatments or material farming? Patient treatments provide guaranteed 5,000 Treasure Coins per heal (25,000-50,000 daily). Material farming offers supplementary income but lacks quantified rewards, making treatments the primary source.

How long to max out Healer profession? Progressing through all five Silver Needle Sect ranks requires 4-8 weeks of daily treatments. Earning 20-40 notebooks daily plus 500 weekly Season Shop purchases determines speed.

Which profession has higher market demand? Healer services maintain consistent demand for group content and rankings. Scholar talismans face variable demand based on meta builds. Healer offers more stable market positioning.

Should beginners choose Healer or Scholar? Beginners benefit from Healer due to guaranteed 5,000 Treasure Coin rewards per treatment, predictable Career Notebook progression, and minimal market knowledge requirements. 10,000 Coin unlock breaks even after two treatments.